If you’re planning a roof upgrade or replacement, you’re likely considering asphalt shingles or metal roofing. Both materials are popular among homeowners, but they serve different needs. Asphalt shingles are widely used due to their affordability and traditional look, while metal roofing is known for its durability and energy efficiency.

Your decision should factor in cost, lifespan, maintenance, energy efficiency, and weather resistance. If you live in North Carolina, where hot summers, storms, and hurricanes are common, you need a roof that can handle the local climate.

This guide will walk you through the pros and cons of asphalt vs. metal roofing, helping you make an informed decision for your home.

Cost Comparison: Which Roofing Material is More Affordable?

Budget is often the first concern when homeowners are choosing a new roof. Asphalt shingles generally cost less upfront, while metal roofing is a long-term investment with higher initial costs.

Asphalt Roofing Costs:

  • Pros: Asphalt shingles are more affordable than metal, making them a budget-friendly choice for most homeowners. The installation process is also quicker and less labor-intensive, which reduces costs.
  • Cons: Although the upfront price is lower, asphalt shingles typically require more repairs and a full replacement sooner than metal roofs, leading to higher long-term costs.

Metal Roofing Costs:

  • Pros: Metal roofing costs more at installation, but it can last two to three times longer than asphalt shingles, making it more cost-effective over time.
  • Cons: The higher initial cost may not be ideal for homeowners who don’t plan to stay in their homes long-term.

Local Insight:

In cities like Charlotte and Raleigh, where property values are rising, many homeowners opt for metal roofing due to its durability and increased resale value. However, in smaller towns with lower property values, asphalt remains the most common choice.

Durability and Lifespan: How Long Does Each Roof Last?

A roof is a major investment, so choosing a material that will last is important. Both asphalt and metal roofing can provide good protection, but their lifespan varies significantly.

Asphalt Roofing Lifespan:

  • Pros: A well-maintained asphalt roof can last 20 to 25 years. Some higher-end options can extend to 30 years.
  • Cons: Asphalt is prone to damage from high winds, hail, and extreme heat, which can shorten its lifespan.

Metal Roofing Lifespan:

  • Pros: Metal roofs last 40 to 70 years, making them one of the longest-lasting roofing materials available. They resist extreme weather and are fireproof.
  • Cons: While they are durable, metal roofs can dent if hit by large hail or debris, depending on the type of metal used.

Local Insight:

North Carolina experiences frequent summer thunderstorms, hurricanes, and occasional hail. Homeowners near the coast, in areas like Wilmington and the Outer Banks, often choose metal roofing because it withstands high winds better than asphalt shingles.

Maintenance and Repairs: Which Roof is Easier to Maintain?

Both materials require maintenance, but asphalt roofs typically need more frequent repairs.

Asphalt Roofing Maintenance:

  • Pros: Individual shingles can be replaced easily if they are damaged. Regular maintenance can help extend their lifespan.
  • Cons: In humid climates, like Fayetteville and Greensboro, asphalt roofs are more prone to algae growth and shingle curling, requiring periodic cleaning and inspections.

Metal Roofing Maintenance:

  • Pros: Requires very little maintenance since metal does not rot, attract mold, or get damaged by insects.
  • Cons: If a metal panel is damaged, repairs can be more expensive and complicated, as full sections may need replacement.

Local Insight:

If you live in an area with high humidity, metal roofing may save you from having to clean and maintain your roof as frequently as asphalt. However, asphalt shingles may be the easier choice for quick and affordable repairs.

Energy Efficiency: Which Roofing Material Lowers Your Energy Bills?

Energy efficiency is becoming a key factor for homeowners looking to cut down on cooling costs.

Asphalt Roofing Energy Efficiency:

  • Pros: Some asphalt shingles now come with reflective coatings to improve energy efficiency.
  • Cons: Standard asphalt absorbs heat, making it less effective at keeping your home cool in the summer. This can lead to higher air conditioning costs, especially in North Carolina’s warm climate.

Metal Roofing Energy Efficiency:

  • Pros: Reflects sunlight instead of absorbing heat, which can reduce summer cooling costs by up to 25 percent. Many homeowners choose light-colored or coated metal roofs for better energy efficiency.
  • Cons: If not properly insulated, metal roofs can make homes feel colder in the winter.

Local Insight:

In cities like Durham and Chapel Hill, where summer temperatures can climb, metal roofs help reduce cooling costs for homeowners who rely heavily on air conditioning.

Storm Resistance: Which Roof Stands Up to Severe Weather?

North Carolina’s weather can be unpredictable, with heavy rain, strong winds, and occasional hurricanes. The right roofing material should withstand these elements.

Asphalt Roofing Storm Resistance:

  • Pros: Some high-quality asphalt shingles are designed to withstand winds up to 130 mph.
  • Cons: In severe storms, shingles can lift, tear, or blow off completely, leading to costly repairs.

Metal Roofing Storm Resistance:

  • Pros: Metal roofs are highly resistant to wind, rain, and fire. They can handle extreme weather better than asphalt.
  • Cons: While they hold up well against high winds, large hail can dent softer metal roofs if they are not impact-resistant.

Local Insight:

Homeowners in hurricane-prone areas like Wilmington prefer metal roofing due to its superior wind resistance. However, asphalt is still common in inland areas where storms are less intense.

Which Roof is Best for You?

Choosing between asphalt shingles and metal roofing depends on your budget, climate, and long-term goals.

Choose Asphalt Roofing If:

  • You want a budget-friendly option with a lower upfront cost.
  • You prefer a traditional look that blends with most home styles.
  • You don’t mind periodic maintenance and repairs.

Choose Metal Roofing If:

  • You want a durable, long-lasting roof that can withstand severe weather.
  • Energy efficiency is a priority, and you want to lower cooling costs.
  • You are looking for a low-maintenance option with long-term savings.

Explore Different Roofing Options with Citadel Contracting

Still unsure which roof type is best for your home? At Citadel Contracting, we specialize in high-quality roofing solutions for homeowners in North Carolina.

Learn more about different roof types and let our experts help you find the perfect fit for your home.

Get your Free QUOTE